LATEST NEWS: HMRC to contact all taxpayers affected by Loan Charge by mid-March. Read more...
Gilbert Tax
Here to help, not to judge
Call us on 0800 011 9625
Experienced team est. 2004
We take control
On your side

Received a letter from HMRC? What to do before you reply

Received a letter from HMRC? What to do before you reply

If you’ve received a letter from HMRC about your tax affairs, don’t ignore it and don’t rush a reply. Check the letter is genuine, work out what type of letter it is, note any deadline, and speak to a specialist before you respond. How you handle the first few weeks can shape the tax, penalties and time involved.

HMRC rarely writes about your tax affairs without believing something needs checking. That doesn’t mean they’re right. Many letters are routine, some are more serious, and almost all are manageable when they’re handled properly from the start. This guide explains what to look for and what to do next.

Is the letter genuine?

Start by making sure the letter really is from HMRC. Scam letters, emails and texts using HMRC’s name are common, and some are convincing.

HMRC publishes a list of genuine letters on GOV.UK. You can check if a letter you’ve received from HMRC is genuine against that list, and find HMRC’s contact details through GOV.UK rather than relying on a number or link you weren’t expecting.

If you have an accountant, ask them too. GOV.UK says that when HMRC opens a compliance check and you have an accountant, HMRC will contact them. Don’t make a payment or share personal details until you’re sure the letter is real.

What type of HMRC letter have you received?

Not every letter from HMRC is an investigation. The type of letter, and which part of HMRC sent it, tells you a lot about how serious it is. Our guide to HMRC letters explains the main HMRC departments and what their letters usually mean.

‍Nudge and campaign letters. HMRC sends standard letters to large groups of people, for example where they’ve received data about rental income or overseas accounts. HMRC’s own guidance says these “one to many” letters are not compliance checks. They usually invite you to review your affairs and, if something needs correcting, to put it right through a route such as the Let Property Campaign or the Worldwide Disclosure Facility. They still deserve a careful response. If something does need correcting, coming forward before HMRC opens a check gives you the best position on penalties.

‍Compliance check or enquiry letters. These say HMRC are checking a particular return or period. An aspect enquiry looks at one part of a return, such as an expense claim. A full enquiry looks at the return as a whole. For individuals, these letters usually come from HMRC’s day-to-day compliance teams. Read more about income tax investigations.‍

Requests for information. HMRC usually asks for records informally first. If that doesn’t work, they can issue a formal information notice, which carries legal obligations and penalties. Knowing which one you have is important and we cover it below.

‍Letters from the Fraud Investigation Service. These are more serious. A letter enclosing Code of Practice 9 means HMRC suspect tax fraud and are offering the Contractual Disclosure Facility. You have 60 days from receiving the offer to accept or reject it. Code of Practice 8 is used for civil investigations where Code of Practice 9 isn’t used, often involving tax avoidance or a potentially significant loss of tax. If you receive either, take specialist advice before you reply.

‍Visit letters. HMRC may ask to visit your home or business premises, often to check VAT, PAYE or employment matters. Find out more about HMRC visits.

If a letter refers to a criminal investigation or invites you to an interview under caution, the matter will typically be referred to a specialist solicitor. We can point you to the right help.

What should you do in the first few days?

The first few days set the tone for everything that follows. Whatever type of letter you’ve received, these steps protect your position:

  • Don’t ignore it. A missed deadline can lead HMRC to issue a formal notice, with penalties if that notice isn’t complied with.
  • Don’t phone HMRC to explain. Anything you say can be noted, and it can widen the check before you understand what HMRC are looking at.
  • Note the details. Write down the deadline, the tax and period involved, and exactly what HMRC are asking for.
  • Keep every record as it is. Don’t alter, delete or tidy up anything.
  • Check for fee protection insurance. You may have cover through your accountant, a trade body or a business policy. Tell the insurer early if their terms require it.
  • Speak to a specialist before you reply. A short conversation can confirm how serious the letter is and what a proportionate response looks like.
  • Keep filing and paying on time. Your other tax obligations carry on while the check runs.

What can HMRC ask for, and do you have to provide everything?

HMRC can ask for information and documents that are reasonably required to check your tax position. That’s the legal test in Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008.

HMRC usually starts with an informal request. If they don’t get what they want, they can issue a formal information notice. A formal notice is different: if you don’t comply, you can face an initial penalty of £300 and then daily penalties of up to £60. You can usually appeal against a formal notice within 30 days. The exceptions are requests for statutory records, and notices the tax tribunal has already approved.

Our experience is that HMRC often ask for more than they’re entitled to. When that extra information is handed over, it usually leads to more questions, more cost and more delay. We review every request against what the law allows, provide what is relevant, and politely challenge what isn’t. Read more about HMRC information notices.

Do you have to attend a meeting with HMRC?

No. In a civil compliance check, HMRC’s own factsheet says you can choose whether to have a meeting. That’s different from a formal information or inspection notice, which you can’t simply ignore.

A meeting can still be useful. It can clear up questions quickly and show HMRC you’re engaging. The key is preparation: knowing what HMRC are likely to ask, agreeing what’s on the agenda, and having an experienced adviser with you. A meeting agreed without preparation can hand HMRC control of the enquiry.

My accountant prepared my return. Can HMRC still investigate me?

Yes. HMRC can check any return, whoever prepared it, and you remain responsible for what it says. HMRC’s guidance is clear that you can’t appoint an agent and then deny responsibility for your tax affairs.

That doesn’t mean you’re automatically penalised for an accountant’s mistake. Penalties for errors depend on whether you took reasonable care. HMRC say that using a tax adviser with the appropriate expertise will normally count as reasonable care, provided you gave them accurate and complete information.

If HMRC have written about a return your accountant prepared, speak to your accountant early. Many deal with routine queries themselves and bring in a specialist when an enquiry becomes complex or contentious. We work alongside accountants as well as directly with individuals, so your accountant can stay involved.

How far back can HMRC go?

For a Self Assessment return filed on time, HMRC normally have 12 months from the date they received it to open an enquiry. The window is longer for late or amended returns.

Outside that window, HMRC can still raise a discovery assessment if they believe tax has been lost. The normal limit is 4 years from the end of the tax year. It extends to 6 years if the loss was caused by carelessness, and to 20 years if it was deliberate.

That’s one reason the type of error matters so much. How HMRC categorises your behaviour affects how far back they can go, as well as the size of any penalty. It’s also why a specialist will check that an enquiry has been opened within the time allowed.

How long does an HMRC investigation take?

There’s no fixed timescale. Some straightforward checks are resolved quickly. A full enquiry, a business check or a Fraud Investigation Service case can take much longer.

In our experience, length depends on three things: how complex your affairs are, how much information HMRC asks for, and how well the enquiry is managed. Enquiries drift when information is handed over without a plan and each answer prompts another question. They move faster when HMRC gets what they need, clearly presented, and nothing irrelevant.

If an enquiry has run on without good reason, you can apply to the tax tribunal to direct HMRC to close it. The tribunal will do so unless HMRC can show reasonable grounds for keeping it open.

What happens if HMRC finds an error?

If HMRC concludes that tax is due, you’ll normally pay the extra tax plus interest from the date it should have been paid. HMRC may also charge a penalty.

Penalties depend on behaviour. There’s no penalty if you took reasonable care. For UK matters, the maximum penalty is 30% of the potential lost revenue (broadly, the extra tax due) for a careless error, 70% for a deliberate one, and 100% where it was deliberate and concealed. Higher rates can apply to offshore matters. Penalties are reduced when you disclose and help HMRC, and the reductions are largest when you come forward before HMRC starts a check.

If you disagree with HMRC’s decision, you can usually appeal within 30 days of the decision letter, and either ask for an HMRC review or take the case to the tax tribunal. Read more about the HMRC appeal process.

How Gilbert Tax can help

Gilbert Tax specialise in HMRC enquiries, disclosures and tax disputes. It’s all we do. Our team includes former HMRC investigators and the former leader of Ernst & Young’s tax investigation team in the North of England, with over 80 years’ combined experience and over 30 years of dealing with Code of Practice 9 investigations.

We take control of your enquiry and deal with HMRC on your behalf. We make sure HMRC gets what the law allows and no more, so you can focus on your life and business. We’re here to help, not to judge. See our full range of tax investigation services.

We’re based in West Yorkshire, with access to meeting space in Newcastle and London, and we act for clients across England, Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland.

For helpful, no obligation and confidential advice, call 0800 011 9625 or email scott.gilbert@gilberttax.co.uk. You can also contact us online.

‍

Frequently asked questions

Does a letter from HMRC mean I’ve done something wrong?

Not necessarily. Some letters are standard “one to many” letters sent to large groups of people, and HMRC’s own guidance says these are not compliance checks. Even a formal enquiry only means HMRC thinks something needs checking. It doesn’t mean they’re right.

‍Will HMRC contact my accountant instead of me?

If you have an accountant, GOV.UK says HMRC will contact them about a compliance check. Letters can still come to you directly, so tell your accountant as soon as one arrives and agree who will deal with HMRC.

What documents should I gather?

Start with the records for the tax years and taxes named in the letter: tax returns, bank statements, invoices, receipts and any business accounts. Keep them exactly as they are. Don’t send anything until you know what HMRC are entitled to ask for, because extra information usually leads to extra questions.

Can I refuse an HMRC visit?

It depends on whether HMRC are asking or using a formal power. You can choose whether to agree to a meeting, but you can’t ignore a formal information or inspection notice, and GOV.UK warns there may be a penalty for refusing an inspection. Take advice before you agree to, or turn down, a visit.

Is the first conversation with Gilbert Tax free?

Yes. Your first conversation with us is free, confidential and carries no obligation. We’ll tell you how serious the letter looks, what your options are, and whether you need us. If we don’t think we can help, we’ll say so.

Contact Our Team

Get in touch with us for confidential and no-obligation tax advice.

Call us on:
0800 011 9625

Email us at:
scott.gilbert@gilberttax.co.uk