Two taxpayers who both own and let a number of properties have received £300 fixed penalties after having their appeals for the decision to be overturned denied. Sarah Duncan and Khalid Mahmood, both of which were being represented by the same adviser, had received information notices from HMRC issued under Schedule 36, Finance Act 2008, for not notifying HMRC of their properties chargeability.
Whilst both individuals had filed their tax returns, insufficient information was provided to satisfy HMRC's requests, outlined in the initial information notices. Consequently £300 fixed penalties were issued. When the individuals challenged both the notices and the penalties, both were upheld by the tribunal.
The reasoning for the decision and the ultimate failure to overturn the information notices comes in two parts. Firstly, some of the information HMRC requested was statutory records, which the law states much be provided when asked for. Secondly, only limited information was provided in the individuals' tax returns and therefore the information HMRC requested was reasonably required.
Read the full article here.
© Gilbert Tax Consultants LLP 2019Registered in England & Wales No. 0C 309788VAT No. 847 880575
We are bound by the ethical guidelines of the Chartered Institute of Taxation and any other regulatory requirement. We endeavour to provide accurate information, however,
the content of this site is for general information only and should not be taken to be tax or legal advice which must always be tailored to the appropriate circumstances of each individual.